update to focus on why this is still open

diff --git a/doc/todo/transitive_transfers.mdwn b/doc/todo/transitive_transfers.mdwn
index 9710402f04b862a46625a32851b059ab30f45668..ff0e57ba9fc6e1c7688b84e21ddbb0b3b307b458 100644 (file)
--- a/doc/todo/transitive_transfers.mdwn
+++ b/doc/todo/transitive_transfers.mdwn
@@ -1,77 +1,29 @@
-I have this situation:
+[[!meta title="streaming for transitive transfers"]]
 
-* `marcos`: home server, canonical repository with all my files
-  (`group=backup`)
-* `angela`: laptop, with a subset of the files (`group=manual`)
-* `VHS`: backup external USB storage, should have a redundant copy of
-  all files (`group=manual`)
+This todo was originally about `git-annex copy --from --to`, which got
+implemented, but without the ability to stream content between the two
+remotes.
 
-directly connecting the external USB drive to `marcos` is annoying, so
-I usually connect it to `angela` instead, which doesn't have all the
-files.
+So this todo remains open, but is now only concerned with
+streaming an object that is being received from one remote out to another
+remote without first needing to buffer the whole object on disk.
 
-This brings up the peculiar situation that I cannot actually backup
-all the files to `VHS` from `angela`, without first copying them
-locally.
+git-annex's remote interface does not currently support that.
+`retrieveKeyFile` stores the object into a file. And `storeKey`
+sends an object file to a remote.
 
-I have a few issues with that:
+The interface would need to be extended to support this, and the external
+special remote interface as well. As well as git remotes and special
+remotes needing to be updated to support the new interface.
 
- 1. it fails silently: if I try to copy to `VHS` and the file is not on
-    `angela`, it silently fails:
-   
-        [997]anarcat@angela:mp3$ git annex drop nothere
-        (recording state in git...)
-        [998]anarcat@angela:mp3$ git annex copy --to VHS nothere
-        [999]anarcat@angela:mp3$ git annex find --in VHS nothere
-        [1001]anarcat@angela:mp3$ git annex list nothere
-        here
-        |VHS
-        ||htcones
-        |||marcos
-        ||||web
-        |||||bittorrent
-        ||||||htconesdumb
-        |||||||
-        ___X___ nothere
-        [1002]anarcat@angela:mp3$
-        
-    this shouldn't silently fail to copy: it should warn me that it
-    can't find a file to copy, at least.
+There's also a question of buffering. If a object is being received from a
+remote faster than it is being sent to the other remote, it has to be
+buffered somewhere, eg not in memory. Or the receive interface needs to
+include a way to get the sender to pause.
 
- 1. it takes up more disk space: i need to download all the missing
-    files locally before I can transfer them to `VHS`. here's the way
-    I make sure files are transfered properly on `VHS`:
-   
-        git annex copy --to VHS --not --in VHS
-        git annex get --not --in VHS
-        git annex copy --to VHS --not --in VHS
-        git annex drop --not --in 'here@{yesterday}'
-        
-    the latter line is expecially problematic, because it is not
-    accurate...
+----
 
- 1. it's slower: i need to write files locally before I can transfer
-    them. ideally, those files would be streamed, or at least I would
-    need to buffer locally only one file at a time and not the whole
-    batch.
-
-Maybe I am missing something obvious here and there are other ways of
-doing this. I am running `6.20160902+gitgbc49d8a-1~ndall+1`.
-
-I know I could setup `angela` to be in the `transfer` group, but then
-files I don't want would end up stored on `angela`: files that are
-missing from other remotes, for example. Even worse, some files I *do*
-want could be candidates for removal on `angela` because they have
-been propagated everywhere, whereas I have a select set of files
-(hence `group=manual`) that are present in `angela` that I want to
-stay there.
-
-It seems to me at least #1 above should be fixed: `copy` shouldn't
-succeed when it can't comply with the requested preferred content
-expression.
-
-Somehow, I expected this to work, and maybe that's the core issue here:
-
-    git annex copy --from marcos --to VHS nothere
-
-Thanks for considering this! -- [[anarcat]]
+Recieving to a file, and sending from the same file as it grows is one
+possibility, since that would handle buffering, and it might avoid needing
+to change interfaces as much. It would still need a new interface since the
+current one does not guarantee the file is written in-order.